Welcome to BookBoardz.com!
FAQFAQ   SearchSearch      ProfileProfile    Private MessagesPrivate Messages   Log in/Register/PasswordLog in/Register/Password

Rereading Vonnegut.

 
   Book Forums (Home) -> Kurt Vonnegut RSS
Next:  Kurt Vonnegut: Vonnegut for Library Community Foundation on June 20th  
Author Message
murmur

External


Since: Jun 27, 2004
Posts: 1



(Msg. 1) Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2004 9:59 am
Post subject: Rereading Vonnegut.
Archived from groups: alt>books>kurt-vonnegut (more info?)

I've been a fan of Vonnegut for 20 years or so now, since we started
reading Slaughterhouse Five in a high school English class only to have
some parents complain. The english teacher was ordered to take the
books back and have the class move on to some less "dirty" book. Piqued
my interest enough to pick up a copy of my own.

Since then, I've read every book he's written, a couple of times. If
anyone asks who my favorite author is I say "Vonnegut". I'm a fan.


So, this summer rolled around and I decided to reread everything. I've
lost or given away most of my copies of his stuff so I started ordering
a book or two at a time, in order, and began reading them.

I'm finishing Breakfast of Champions now. Ready to start on Slapstick.



Maybe I'm just older now and the counter-cultural themes don't tittilate
me as much, but good god I'm finding these books horribly depressing.
They're fun reads, don't get me wrong. I still laugh a lot and admire
them...but to be honest, its turning into a struggle to continue
reading.

So much negativity. So much cynicism. I'm surprised at my reaction to
this stuff. I was looking forward to my Vonnegut Summer. I'll continue
it...hoping that the ennui and malaise will abate and I'll be able to
take more from this than "...babies. Damn it, you've got to be kind!"

Anyone else had a similar reaction after having been a loyal fan for so
many years?

Did you get over it?


-pete

 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
yowanda42

External


Since: Aug 29, 2003
Posts: 2



(Msg. 2) Posted: Mon Jun 28, 2004 4:12 am
Post subject: Re: Rereading Vonnegut. [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

Back in 2001, I did pretty much the same thing. I first started reading
Vonnegut in high school in the early ninties. So, after reading
everything, in 2001 I decided to read all of his books in the order they
were written. I still thoughly enjoyed them all, but I did also find it
somewhat depressing. Of course it didn't help when 9/11 happened. I
had to put Vonnegut on hiatus while I read some slightly more cheerful
stuff. But I got back into Vonnegut after a couple weeks and finished
up my project. In the end I was very glad I did it. I think it helped
bring out different themes and similarites that I didn't notice before.
It was also interesting to see how all the books evolved. And the
best part was that I got to finish it all off by seeing Vonnegut speak
in person in Chicago in October, 2001! So I say, don't fret too much.
I didn't suffer any long lasting depression, and I still love Vonnegut.

Heather

Peter Register wrote:
 > I've been a fan of Vonnegut for 20 years or so now, since we started
 > reading Slaughterhouse Five in a high school English class only to have
 > some parents complain. The english teacher was ordered to take the
 > books back and have the class move on to some less "dirty" book. Piqued
 > my interest enough to pick up a copy of my own.
 >
 > Since then, I've read every book he's written, a couple of times. If
 > anyone asks who my favorite author is I say "Vonnegut". I'm a fan.
 >
 >
 > So, this summer rolled around and I decided to reread everything. I've
 > lost or given away most of my copies of his stuff so I started ordering
 > a book or two at a time, in order, and began reading them.
 >
 > I'm finishing Breakfast of Champions now. Ready to start on Slapstick.
 >
 >
 >
 > Maybe I'm just older now and the counter-cultural themes don't tittilate
 > me as much, but good god I'm finding these books horribly depressing.
 > They're fun reads, don't get me wrong. I still laugh a lot and admire
 > them...but to be honest, its turning into a struggle to continue
 > reading.
 >
 > So much negativity. So much cynicism. I'm surprised at my reaction to
 > this stuff. I was looking forward to my Vonnegut Summer. I'll continue
 > it...hoping that the ennui and malaise will abate and I'll be able to
 > take more from this than "...babies. Damn it, you've got to be kind!"
 >
 > Anyone else had a similar reaction after having been a loyal fan for so
 > many years?
 >
 > Did you get over it?
 >
 >
 > -pete<!-- ~MESSAGE_AFTER~ -->

 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
zapvon

External


Since: Jun 28, 2004
Posts: 3



(Msg. 3) Posted: Mon Jun 28, 2004 6:28 pm
Post subject: Re: Rereading Vonnegut. [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

Hi, Pete!

I don't think the problem is that KV's books are "horribly depressing."
IMO, it's just that the whole world is horribly depressing. Nothing's been
the same since we had Our Bad Day. The terrorists took much, but stealing
our collective senses of humor is the ONE thing I'll never forgive them for.
(To be honest, our internal provocateurs are the ones who have terrorized me
the most, personally. Economically, spiritually, and employment-wise.
Stifling dissent and Buying a few thousand Million Dollar Bombs while our
own schools, factories, and hospitals close down due to lack of interest. I
no longer recognize my birthland. We see pictures of our guards torturing,
molesting, and abusing naked, hand-cuffed prisoners of both sexes and many
of our kind think this is an honorable thing, or at least an acceptable form
of symbolic retribution. A nearly nationwide mindset like that makes me
think of Howard Campbell's Nazis and the people who ignored the Crematoriums
next door for six years. "What? How was I to know? I didn't smell
anything. I just live here.")

After all that, old KV seems like a real optimist. Our sense of humor? So
it goes.

I'm rereading all of Mr. V's books for the first time in a couple of years
myself. (That's why I decided to come back here. That, and I missed
everybody. Hi, Dave! Any of the rest of the old gang around? Hear from
Melissa or Kazak or Dagney or anybody lately?) I still find KV to be
Essential. He'll always be my favorite. (Hunter Thompson and Tom Robbins
rate at least an honorable mention, though.)

(Just read Heather's thread before I hit the "send" button. You look like
you felt about the same as me! I was rereading them about that time, too.
Had to take a break When I came back, I saw the parallels, too. That's one
thing about KV I really love, and a big part of why I have to keep going
back. He's so timeless. He was about fifty years ahead of his time on that
first book. Closing down all the factories, demoted to being a Nation of
Reeks and Wrecks... I wonder how close we are to first, Slapstick, then
Galapagos?)

Mr. V's inherent cynicism and negativity are pretty low-key compared to
living in the USA in 2004. Odd you should mention BoC and Slapstick. Those
two and Hocus Pocus are always the first ones I reread. Then Deadeye Dick
and Jailbird and Bluebeard. (I have a regular route.) Just finished
Galapagos and Mother Night, started Rosewater again just last night.
Thought it was time to stop in for a visit. I was wondering if anybody had
anything to say about Reagan. Looks like no one noticed. Perhaps it's for
the best.

---doug
 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
zapvon

External


Since: Jun 28, 2004
Posts: 3



(Msg. 4) Posted: Mon Jun 28, 2004 6:30 pm
Post subject: Re: Rereading Vonnegut. [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

Hi, Pete!

I don't think the problem is that KV's books are "horribly depressing."
IMO, it's just that the whole world is horribly depressing. Nothing's been
the same since we had Our Bad Day. The terrorists took much, but stealing
our collective senses of humor is the ONE thing I'll never forgive them for.
(To be honest, our internal provocateurs are the ones who have terrorized me
the most, personally. Economically, spiritually, and employment-wise.
Stifling dissent and Buying a few thousand Million Dollar Bombs while our
own schools, factories, and hospitals close down due to lack of interest. I
no longer recognize my birthland. We see pictures of our guards torturing,
molesting, and abusing naked, hand-cuffed prisoners of both sexes and many
of our kind think this is an honorable thing, or at least an acceptable form
of symbolic retribution. A nearly nationwide mindset like that makes me
think of Howard Campbell's Nazis and the people who ignored the Crematoriums
next door for six years. "What? How was I to know? I didn't smell
anything. I just live here.")

After all that, old KV seems like a real optimist. Our sense of humor? So
it goes.

I'm rereading all of Mr. V's books for the first time in a couple of years
myself. (That's why I decided to come back here. That, and I missed
everybody. Hi, Dave! Any of the rest of the old gang around? Hear from
Melissa or Kazak or Dagney or anybody lately?) I still find KV to be
Essential. He'll always be my favorite. (Hunter Thompson and Tom Robbins
rate at least an honorable mention, though.)

(Just read Heather's thread before I hit the "send" button. You look like
you felt about the same as me! I was rereading them about that time, too.
Had to take a break When I came back, I saw the parallels, too. That's one
thing about KV I really love, and a big part of why I have to keep going
back. He's so timeless. He was about fifty years ahead of his time on that
first book. Closing down all the factories, demoted to being a Nation of
Reeks and Wrecks... I wonder how close we are to first, Slapstick, then
Galapagos?)

Mr. V's inherent cynicism and negativity are pretty low-key compared to
living in the USA in 2004. Odd you should mention BoC and Slapstick. Those
two and Hocus Pocus are always the first ones I reread. Then Deadeye Dick
and Jailbird and Bluebeard. (I have a regular route.) Just finished
Galapagos and Mother Night, started Rosewater again just last night.
Thought it was time to stop in for a visit. I was wondering if anybody had
anything to say about Reagan. Looks like no one noticed. Perhaps it's for
the best.

---doug
 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
zapvon

External


Since: Jun 28, 2004
Posts: 3



(Msg. 5) Posted: Mon Jun 28, 2004 6:30 pm
Post subject: Re: Rereading Vonnegut. [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

Hi, Pete!

I don't think the problem is that KV's books are "horribly depressing."
IMO, it's just that the whole world is horribly depressing. Nothing's been
the same since we had Our Bad Day. The terrorists took much, but stealing
our collective senses of humor is the ONE thing I'll never forgive them for.
(To be honest, our internal provocateurs are the ones who have terrorized me
the most, personally. Economically, spiritually, and employment-wise.
Stifling dissent and Buying a few thousand Million Dollar Bombs while our
own schools, factories, and hospitals close down due to lack of interest. I
no longer recognize my birthland. We see pictures of our guards torturing,
molesting, and abusing naked, hand-cuffed prisoners of both sexes and many
of our kind think this is an honorable thing, or at least an acceptable form
of symbolic retribution. A nearly nationwide mindset like that makes me
think of Howard Campbell's Nazis and the people who ignored the Crematoriums
next door for six years. "What? How was I to know? I didn't smell
anything. I just live here.")

After all that, old KV seems like a real optimist. Our sense of humor? So
it goes.

I'm rereading all of Mr. V's books for the first time in a couple of years
myself. (That's why I decided to come back here. That, and I missed
everybody. Hi, Dave! Any of the rest of the old gang around? Hear from
Melissa or Kazak or Dagney or anybody lately?) I still find KV to be
Essential. He'll always be my favorite. (Hunter Thompson and Tom Robbins
rate at least an honorable mention, though.)

(Just read Heather's thread before I hit the "send" button. You look like
you felt about the same as me! I was rereading them about that time, too.
Had to take a break When I came back, I saw the parallels, too. That's one
thing about KV I really love, and a big part of why I have to keep going
back. He's so timeless. He was about fifty years ahead of his time on that
first book. Closing down all the factories, demoted to being a Nation of
Reeks and Wrecks... I wonder how close we are to first, Slapstick, then
Galapagos?)

Mr. V's inherent cynicism and negativity are pretty low-key compared to
living in the USA in 2004. Odd you should mention BoC and Slapstick. Those
two and Hocus Pocus are always the first ones I reread. Then Deadeye Dick
and Jailbird and Bluebeard. (I have a regular route.) Just finished
Galapagos and Mother Night, started Rosewater again just last night.
Thought it was time to stop in for a visit. I was wondering if anybody had
anything to say about Reagan. Looks like no one noticed. Perhaps it's for
the best.

---doug
 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
bbb

External


Since: May 09, 2004
Posts: 7



(Msg. 6) Posted: Thu Jul 01, 2004 4:50 am
Post subject: Re: Rereading Vonnegut. [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

"Bad ideas can cause disease." -kv
 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
obscura

External


Since: Jul 03, 2003
Posts: 38



(Msg. 7) Posted: Sun Jul 04, 2004 10:05 am
Post subject: Re: Rereading Vonnegut. [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

dugbaker cast forth electrons:

 > I'm rereading all of Mr. V's books for the first time in a couple of
 > years myself. (That's why I decided to come back here. That, and I
 > missed everybody. Hi, Dave! Any of the rest of the old gang around?
 > Hear from Melissa or Kazak or Dagney or anybody lately?) I still find
 > KV to be Essential. He'll always be my favorite.

Hi, Doug! Good to hear from you again. Missed your (type)face around
here.

No, the ones you mention fell away when the political landscape became
so dire, though I'd not suggest any cause and effect. If you dejagoogle
on the froup, you'll see a lot of old, familiar names over the past
several months, but will find in general that the subject matter is
actually about Vonnegut.

Speaking of that, reference this post of mine from last October
<a style='text-decoration: underline;' href="http://xrl.us/ccaz" target="_blank">http://xrl.us/ccaz</a> (Link to groups.google.com) for some material about
Vonnegut which I suspect you may have missed and which I highly
recommend to you.

I assume you've caught Vonnegut's great nonfiction in the last year and
a half or so's issues of IN THESE TIMES <http://www.inthesetimes.com/>.
Another strong recommendation to you, if you haven't. Go there and fish
around the site for it, or do a Google search specific to the main URL,
or do a dejagoogle search specific to announcements here as his articles
and essays appeared.

Hope you continue reading abk-v and pop in when you can. It's the best
way to keep tabs on what's new about KV in terms of what appears on the
Web about him.

All best to you.

--
obscura RemoveThis @null.net ¤ Q: "What targets would you consider fair game for
a satirist today?" A: "Assholes."
-- Kurt Vonnegut, 1/27/03, "In These Times"<!-- ~MESSAGE_AFTER~ -->
 >> Stay informed about: Rereading Vonnegut. 
Back to top
Login to vote
Display posts from previous:   
   Book Forums (Home) -> Kurt Vonnegut All times are: Pacific Time (US & Canada) (change)
Page 1 of 1

 
You can post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum



[ Contact us | Terms of Service/Privacy Policy ]