"William C. Keel" <keel RemoveThis @bildad.astr.ua.edu> wrote in message
news:449c4550$1@news.ua.edu...
> To sidestep the ansthropic principle, and science versus faith,
> and related topics being discussed in a refreshingly civil way -
> can anyone here help me with the origin of a passage? This popped
> into my mind after reading a recent book on Lewis which mentioned
> that, as remarked by one of the youngsters "visiting" during the
> Blitz evacuation, Lewis took some interest in astronomy and
> kept a small telescope. This reminded me of a line which I thought
> was in one of the Screwtape writings, so of course I can't actually
> find it in either of them. Something to the effect that "our
> astronomers in Hell can see the full extent of misery and suffering
> throughout the Universe, unhindered by any merely physical limitations".
> Sounds like Screwtape, but I've evidently conflated something else.
A rather unhelpful answer: I'm pretty sure it's not literal Screwtape in that
it's reasonably striking and I'm fairly sure I would have remembered it if it
was in there. Nor do I remember any such direct quotation anywhere in Lewis.
However, as you say, it sounds very like the sort of thing he would have said.
(Now watch someone prove me wrong

)
Nicholas.
--
"Macbeth" is ... by a playwright who ought, at least on this occasion, to have
written a story, if he had the skill or patience. - JRRT, _On Fairy-Stories_
To email me, use vnicholasv RemoveThis @vinchbare-yv.vfsnetv.co.uk,
removing all occurrences of the letter "v".