This is our 241st edition, with two books. I'm running pretty late
today so I'm going to try and be brief.
This week we have...
Avengers: The Initiative #7 - 3 Stars
X-Factor #25 - 3.25 Stars
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S
P
A
C
E
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
-
Avengers: The Initiative #7 - "Triple Threat" (Writer: Dan Slott,
Artist: Stefano Caselli, Color Art:
Daniele Rudoni)
The Scarlet Spiders go publicly into action when something is stolen
from one of the Initiative's top scientists... and Peter Parker is
annoyed to see three people swinging around in his suit.
The basics of the plot is okay, but some of it's a little stilted...
Peter Parker's verbal monologue bemoaning his fate, for example (it
would have worked much better as a thought bubble). It was also
full of a little bit of oddness, like the idea that if May dies
she'll be buried under the wrong name. One would assume that once
she dies (if that were to happen), the main reason for giving her a
fake identity would be passed, and you could tell the doctors that
she was really May Parker.
As to the revelation of the identity of the Scarlet Spiders... well,
I had a feeling it was going to be that way about halfway through the
issue, and I have to say I'm getting a little tired of waiting to see
certain people in the Initiative leadership get what's coming to them.
So, a little bit of a weaker issue. I also find I'm tiring a bit of
the
title's tendency to focus on one character with every issue, because
the
fact is I don't really care much about most of them, and the one issue
of
spotlight seems to give short shrift to everybody else. Even when a
character I like is spotlighted, it feels like it's going to be so
long
before I see them again. I'd prefer a more standard approach which
allows the reader to get attached to groups of characters at once.
Review: 3 stars
-
X-Factor #25 - "Messiah Complex, Chapter Three" (Writer: Peter
David,
Penciler: Scot Eaton, Inker: John Dell, Colorist:
Frank
D'Armata)
Rictor attempts to infiltrate the purifiers, and Jamie goes on a
mission
to investigate the future for Forge.
This is my first taste of Messiah Complex. I decided not to go and
read
the whole crossover because, frankly ever since Decimation my interest
in the X-Books has been severely waning. Messiah Complex will either
reverse that bad idea, in which case I might become interested in
the books after that, or it will not, in which case I really don't
care much what happens in it. However, I do still like a few of the
X-books involved in the crossover, like X-Factor.
The problem then becomes, do I bother to read those parts of the
crossover in the titles I'm already buying? Or should I just sit the
whole thing out?
This issue didn't really sell me on one plan or the other. Since I'll
be buying the next part of the crossover (New X-Men), I'll have a
better
idea then. I didn't feel spectacularly lost reading this issue,
because
I've read some of the press for Messiah complex. I suspect my ease
in
following the story is also indicative of a slow start to the mini as
a
whole... in short, it doesn't seem that a whole lot has happened.
In this issue really not a whole lot seems to be happening either, at
least in terms of the overall storyline, but there are a few cool
developments for X-Factor's cast as a whole, which elevate the book
into
my Pick of the Week.
Review: 3.25 stars
-
Well, that's it for this week folks. Next week, according to the
shipping list, there'll be two books. There's New X-Men #44 and
Loners #6.
See you next time...
Peter Dimitriadis
http://www.unreachablestar.net
The Unreachable Star - Comics & SF News/Reviews/Opinion
FAQ
Search
Profile
Private Messages
Log in
