"Ernest Fairchild" <ernestf.DeleteThis@delphidude.com> writes:
>"Richard Schultz" <schultr.DeleteThis@mail.biu.ack.il> wrote in message
>news:ca9i2v$448$1@news.iucc.ac.il...
>> Did they reprint Foundation with its original text (an atomic plant
>> on, IIRC, Vega "exploding") or with the later revised text (the atomic
>> plant undergoing "meltdown")?
>Either could happen, theoretically, so why would they change it?
For the 1980s editions of the Foundation Trilogy Asimov made a
number of little changes, apparently to remove things he felt just too
pulpish to let stand. One can argue whether an atomic plant exploding
is more purple than one melting down; the line that gets a number of
folks upset is Salvor Hardin no longer says ``if you ask me, the Galaxy
is going to pot!'' Now he just says if you ask him, the Galactic Empire
is dying.
There are other little changes; I don't know that anybody's
made a change list. The only other one I remember is oddly removing
the Dinner on Rossum over in the Search By The Mule. It all seems
like fixing things that aren't broken.
--
Joseph Nebus
------------------------------------------------------------------------------<!-- ~MESSAGE_AFTER~ -->
>> Stay informed about: New Asimov hardcovers