The hidden white victims of racism

Last week's horrifying trial of three Asians is part of a worrying trend,
says Brendan Montague

The Sunday Times November 12, 2006



No one who saw Angela Donald giving her dignified statement that "justice
had been done" outside the High Court in Edinburgh as the racist murderers
of her 15-year-old son were jailed last week could feel anything but
sympathy. For Margaret Massey there was more, though - a sense of
fellow-feeling and anger.
Kriss Donald was snatched off the street by an Asian gang and subjected to a
terrible ordeal: beaten, stabbed, doused in petrol and set ablaze. Massey's
son Lee, a rugby player, was also the subject of a racially motivated attack
when he was set upon by a gang of Iraqi asylum seekers "out looking for
someone" to hurt.


He and two friends were stabbed in a car park in Dewsbury, West Yorkshire,
in October 2003. Lee was then thrown into the air and suffered devastating
brain injuries when one of the gang used a car to run him down. Three years
later he has not fully recovered.
Massey still feels aggrieved that - in her view - the police inquiry was
hindered by political correctness because officers feared that reporting
that a white man had been so brutally attacked by asylum seekers would
further fuel racial tensions following several such brawls in the area.
"The police didn't charge 13 members of the gang even though I believe there
was some evidence," she says.
"If our Lee had run over one of the Iraqis he would have been arrested right
away and sent to prison for the rest of his life. The police are nervous
when white people are attacked. In this area this is happening more and more
often."
The killing of Stephen Lawrence 13 years ago sparked off an orgy of
soul-searching throughout liberal Britain.
But we have never quite acknowledged that violence comes from both sides.
Gavin Hopley, 19, was kicked to death by up to eight Asian men in Oldham in
February 2002. Six men were convicted of violent disorder and theft offences
but no one has been convicted of his murder.
An Asian gang was also responsible for the violent killing of 17-year-old
Ross Parker, who was savagely stabbed with hunting knives during an attack
in Peterborough in 2001. David Lees, 23, was run over and killed during a
fight between whites and a gang of Asians in Prestwich, Manchester, only
last month.
There has been numerous inquiries and new legislation since the Lawrence
case and almost everyone concerned with race relations will confirm that
policing in cases involving race has improved immeasurably since that tragic
event.
However, the debate about the white victims of racist attacks seems to have
progressed no further in the past 10 years - because of fears of "political
correctness" and the threat of the far right making political capital out of
personal tragedy.
Sir Ian Blair, Britain's most senior police officer, even attacked the press
as "institutionally racist" in January this year because cases such as the
killing of Tom ap Rhys Pryce, the solicitor, had gained more publicity than
the equally terrible death on the same day of Balbir Matharu, who had tried
to stop thieves ripping the radio from his car.
An extensive search of national and regional newspaper reports, however,
shows that cases involving black and minority ethnic victims are widely
reported, while there is an almost total boycott of stories involving the
white victims of similar attacks. Is this because newspapers fear their
reports appearing on BNP leaflets, or because the police are less likely to
issue appeals for help?
Peter Fahy, chief constable of Cheshire police and spokesman on race issues
for the Association of Chief Police Officers, said: "A lot of police
officers and other professionals feel almost the best thing to do is to try
and avoid [discussing such attacks] for fear of being criticised. This is
not healthy."
The silence means it is impossible to know how many white people are victims
of racist attacks in today's multicultural Britain and whether they are
right to feel aggrieved that the attacks they suffer do not appear to get
the same recognition as those of black victims.

Take the case of Christopher Yates, who had been out celebrating a birthday
with a group of friends in London and, concerned about their safety,
insisted on taking some of the women he was with to a bus stop during a cool
November evening two years ago.
Without warning, the 30-year-old office worker was viciously assaulted by a
gang of drunken Asian men - Sajid Zulfiqar, Zahid Bashir and Imran Maqsood -
who stamped on his head, smashing every bone in his face before killing him.


After the murder the attackers shouted in Urdu, "We have killed the white
man - that will teach an Englishman to interfere in Paki business." Despite
this appalling racism, the three were never convicted for committing a race
crime - which would have meant a heavier sentence.
This led to comparisons with the brutal and unprovoked murder of Anthony
Walker, a young black man who was attacked when walking to a bus stop in
Liverpool with a female friend. The 18-year-old was bludgeoned with an ice
axe by Paul Taylor and Michael Barton, both white, and died later in
hospital.
The attack was undoubtedly racially motivated, but the fact that Taylor and
Barton received sentences nine and three years longer respectively than
their equally racist counterparts in London has led to suspicions that
racist attacks against whites and non-whites are treated differently in the
courts.
At the same time there is growing concern that attacks by Asians and other
ethnic minorities have been steadily increasing, leaving some white people
feeling too scared to enter city areas dominated by Asians and other
minority ethnic groups.
Figures recently published under the Freedom of Information Act seem to
support such fears: of the 58 people killed because of the colour of their
skin between 1995 and 2004, almost half were described as white.
The British Crime Survey reveals that in 2004, 87,000 people who described
themselves as black or minority ethnic (BME) had been victims of what they
believed was a racially motivated crime. They had suffered 49,000 violent
attacks, with 4,000 being wounded.
At the same time a staggering 92,000 white people also said that racism was
the cause of an attack or crime they had suffered. The number of violent
attacks against whites reached 77,000, while the number of white people who
reported being wounded was five times the number of black and minority
ethnic victims at 20,000.
The truth is hard to get at: Jenny Bourne, of the Institute of Race
Relations, says its figures show only eight white victims of racially
motivated killings between 1995 and 2004: "The Kriss Donald case involved an
Asian gang which had been involved in violence already. These cases are
incredibly rare compared with the number of racist attacks on minorities
which take place every day."
What is clear is that unless the attacks on whites are reported and
discussed, the truth about what is happening out there will remain hazy.